Why “Marry Your Best Friend” is Terrible Advice

Like the post? Share with people you love!

“Marry your best friend!”

If I had a dollar for every time I’ve heard this advice, I’d be writing this from a beach somewhere instead of explaining why this well-meaning cliche is ruining marriages.

Everyone says “marry your friend” like it’s some profound wisdom that guarantees a happy marriage.

And then people actually do it.

They marry their childhood friend, their college buddy, the person they’ve known forever, and six months into the marriage, they’re sitting there wondering why friendship didn’t translate into a functional marriage.

“But we were such good friends! We’ve known each other for years! We were so comfortable together!”

Yes.

And now you’re married to someone you’re not attracted to, or who doesn’t share your life goals, or who’s a terrible partner even though they were a great friend.

Friendship and marriage aren’t the same thing.

And “marry your friend” has become one of the most misunderstood pieces of advice in the relationship world.

Let me tell you what it actually means and what it definitely doesn’t mean.

The Myths People Believe About “Marrying Your Friend”

Myth #1: A friend is just someone you’ve known for a long time

So people marry their childhood friend, their high school sweetheart, someone they’ve known since forever, because they think longevity equals friendship.

You can know someone for 20 years and not be compatible with them.

Time doesn’t create compatibility.

It just creates familiarity.

And familiarity is not the same as suitability for marriage.

Myth #2: If you’re friends, you don’t need to date or court properly

“We already know each other so well! We’ve been friends for years! Why do we need to date?”

Because friendship and romantic partnership are completely different relationships!

The way someone shows up as your friend is not necessarily how they’ll show up as your spouse.

Your friend who’s fun and easygoing might be financially irresponsible as a husband.

Your friend who’s always there to listen might be emotionally unavailable in a romantic relationship.

Your friend who shares your sense of humor might have different values about kids, faith, money, or family.

You don’t know someone as a romantic partner until you’ve been in a romantic relationship with them.

Friendship doesn’t give you that information.

Myth #3: Friendship guarantees a good marriage

People think friendship is some magic ingredient that makes everything work.

“We’re best friends, so even when things get hard, we’ll be fine!”

No. You won’t.

Marriage requires things that friendship doesn’t require.

Accountability, sacrifice, managing conflict about money, sex, in-laws, and parenting.

Building a life together, not just hanging out together.

Friendship is not enough.

It’s necessary, but it’s not sufficient.

I’ve seen best friends get married and divorced within a year because they discovered that being good friends doesn’t mean being good spouses.

Myth #4: Friendship means you’ll always get along

Marriage will introduce conflict that friendship never had because the stakes are higher and the expectations are different.

Your friend can flake on plans, and you’re annoyed, but you move on.

Your spouse flakes on responsibilities, and it affects your entire life….your finances, your home, your kids.

The things you tolerate in a friend become dealbreakers in a spouse.

Myth #5: Romantic attraction doesn’t matter as much if you’re friends

This is the dangerous one.

People marry friends they’re not actually attracted to because they’ve been told “attraction fades but friendship lasts.”

And then they’re stuck in a sexless marriage, wondering why they don’t desire their spouse.

Friendship without attraction is just friendship.

It’s not a marriage.

You need both.

And if you’re marrying someone you’re not attracted to just because you’re “such good friends,” you’re setting yourself up for a miserable marriage.

What “Marry Your Friend” Actually Means

It doesn’t mean marry someone you’ve known for a long time.

It means marry someone who has the QUALITIES of a good friend and also the qualities of a good spouse.

Let me break that down.

A friend is someone who:

• Actually likes you (not just loves you, but genuinely enjoys your company)
• Supports you without competing with you
• You can be yourself around without performing
• Shares your values about what matters in life
• You trust, and who trusts you
• Makes you laugh and enjoys your sense of humor
• You’re comfortable with even in silence

Those are friend qualities. And yes, you want those in a spouse.

But you also need:

• Romantic and sexual attraction that goes both ways
• Compatible life goals (kids, career, lifestyle, location)
• Aligned values on the big stuff (money, religion, family, priorities)
• The ability to handle conflict maturely as partners, not just buddies
• Emotional availability in a romantic context, not just a platonic one
• The willingness to do the hard, unglamorous work of marriage
• Actual readiness for commitment, not just comfort in your presence

“Marry your friend” means marry someone you could genuinely be friends with AND who also meets the criteria for being a good spouse.

Not one or the other. Both.

 

Sometimes friendship actually HIDES incompatibility.

You’re so comfortable, so familiar, so used to each other that you overlook the red flags.

You’re not romantically attracted?

“It’s fine, we’re such good friends!”

You want completely different things in life?

“We’ll figure it out, we’ve been friends forever!”

The comfort of friendship can make you ignore deal-breakers you’d never tolerate from someone you were dating.

Because you’re not evaluating them as a potential spouse.

You’re just thinking, “We’re friends, so this should work.”

And then you get married and realize that friendship covered up a lot of problems that marriage is now forcing you to face.

 

I’ve been married for a decade.

And yes, my husband is my friend.

I enjoy being with him. 

But he’s not my husband because he’s my friend.

He’s my husband because he’s a good man who shares my values, who I’m attracted to, who’s committed to making marriage work, and who shows up as a partner when life gets hard.

Friendship is the foundation.

But there’s a whole house that has to be built on top of that foundation.

And if all you have is friendship, if you’re missing the attraction, the compatibility, the commitment, and the values, that foundation isn’t enough.

So when people say “marry your friend,” what they should be saying is:

“Marry someone who meets all the criteria for being a good spouse, AND who you also genuinely like and enjoy being around.”

Like the post? Share with people you love!